Understanding Bad Faith Insurance Practices: Recognizing and Fighting Them in Florida

Insurance policies are meant to provide financial protection in times of need, ensuring that policyholders receive fair compensation for covered losses. However, not all insurance companies operate in good faith. Some engage in tactics that delay, minimize, or deny valid claims—actions known as bad faith insurance practices. Recognizing these tactics and understanding how to fight against them is crucial, especially in a state like Florida, where insurance disputes are common due to frequent natural disasters and a high volume of claims.

What is Bad Faith Insurance?

Bad faith insurance refers to the unethical or dishonest practices by insurance companies to avoid fulfilling their contractual obligations to policyholders. When an insurer refuses to pay a legitimate claim, delays payment unnecessarily, or underpays without reasonable justification, it may be acting in bad faith.

Florida law protects policyholders from such practices through statutes and legal precedents that hold insurers accountable. The Florida Insurance Code and the Unfair Insurance Trade Practices Act provide legal remedies for those affected by bad faith tactics.

Common Examples of Bad Faith Insurance Practices

To identify and combat bad faith practices, it is essential to recognize some of the most common tactics used by insurers. These include:

Unjustified Claim Denials

One of the most prevalent forms of bad faith is the outright denial of a valid insurance claim without providing a reasonable explanation. Insurers may argue that the damage is not covered under the policy, even when it clearly should be.

Delayed Claims Processing

Another common bad faith tactic is unnecessarily delaying the processing of claims. Insurance companies may ask for excessive documentation, repeatedly request information that has already been provided, or simply fail to respond in a timely manner. These delays can cause financial hardship for policyholders who need funds for medical expenses, repairs, or living costs.

Lowball Settlement Offers

Some insurers offer settlements that are far below the actual value of the claim in hopes that the policyholder will accept out of desperation or ignorance of their rights. Adjusters may misrepresent the extent of damages or undervalue losses.

Misrepresentation of Policy Terms

Insurance companies may misinterpret or misrepresent policy terms to deny coverage. They may claim that certain provisions exclude coverage when they do not or fail to disclose the full scope of benefits available to the policyholder.

Failure to Conduct a Proper Investigation

Insurers have a duty to conduct thorough and fair investigations into claims. In bad faith cases, they may ignore key evidence, fail to inspect damage properly, or refuse to consider expert opinions that support the policyholder’s claim.

Unreasonable Requests for Documentation

While insurers are entitled to request proof of loss and other relevant documents, they cannot demand excessive or unnecessary paperwork simply to delay or frustrate the claimant.

Retaliatory Practices

Some insurance companies retaliate against policyholders who challenge their claim denials. This may include increasing premiums, canceling policies, or even blacklisting individuals from obtaining future coverage.

Florida’s Legal Protections Against Bad Faith Insurance

Florida has some of the most comprehensive legal protections for policyholders who experience bad faith insurance practices. Under Florida Statutes § 624.155, policyholders can file a civil remedy notice and pursue legal action if their insurer engages in bad faith conduct.

First-Party vs. Third-Party Bad Faith Claims

Bad faith claims in Florida fall into two primary categories:

• First-party claims: These arise when an insurer acts in bad faith toward its own policyholder, such as failing to pay a homeowner’s or health insurance claim.
• Third-party claims: These involve cases where an insurer refuses to settle or properly defend a claim brought against the insured, such as in auto accident liability cases.

Pre-Suit Notice Requirement

Before filing a bad faith lawsuit, Florida law requires policyholders to file a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) with the Florida Department of Financial Services. This notice provides the insurer with an opportunity to correct its behavior within 60 days.

If the insurer fails to resolve the issue within the timeframe, the policyholder may proceed with a lawsuit seeking damages, including the full value of the claim, attorney fees, and punitive damages in extreme cases.

Combatting Bad Faith Insurance Practices in Florida

If you suspect your insurance company is acting in bad faith, there are several steps you can take to protect your rights and seek fair compensation.

Document Everything

Keep a detailed record of all communications with your insurance company, including emails, letters, and phone call logs. Save copies of your policy, claim documents, and any correspondence related to your case.

Review Your Policy Thoroughly

Understanding your policy’s terms and conditions can help you determine whether the insurer’s actions are legitimate or constitute bad faith.

Request a Written Explanation

If your claim is denied or underpaid, ask for a written explanation detailing the reasons behind the decision. This can be useful in challenging the denial later.

Consult a Skilled Bad Faith Insurance Attorney

Hiring an experienced bad faith insurance attorney can significantly improve your chances of obtaining a fair outcome. Lawyers specializing in insurance disputes can assess your case, negotiate on your behalf, and take legal action if necessary.

File a Complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services

You can file a complaint against your insurer with the Florida Department of Financial Services, which regulates insurance companies and investigates consumer complaints.

Consider Litigation

If your insurer refuses to resolve the issue, filing a lawsuit may be the best course of action. A successful bad faith claim can result in compensation beyond the original claim amount, including legal fees and punitive damages.

Get the Help You Need From a Bad Faith Insurance Attorney

Bad faith insurance practices can leave policyholders feeling helpless and financially strained. However, understanding your rights and the legal protections available in Florida can help you fight unfair treatment. If you suspect your insurance company is acting in bad faith, take proactive steps to document your case, contact an attorney, and pursue legal remedies when necessary. By holding insurers accountable, you can ensure fair treatment and the compensation you deserve.

Share